GoonThe end of SEO as we know it: how AI is reshaping the digital landscape
Search Engine Optimization (SEO), a keystone of the digital marketing world, has long been the source of traffic, revenue, and success for countless businesses. But as we edge closer to 2024, the landscape of SEO is undergoing a transformation so revolutionary that the traditional model is becoming obsolete. Many refer to this as the "death of SEO," but what's driving this transformation? This article delves deeply into the forces reshaping SEO and what businesses and marketers can do to adapt and thrive in this new era.
The video begins with Mike Gaston introducing the topic: 'The death of SEO in 2024.'
How SEO traditionally worked
To understand the seismic shift, it’s crucial to look back at SEO's evolution over the years.
The keyword era
If you’ve been in the marketing world long enough, you'll remember the “keyword era” when Google’s algorithms were simplistic. During these early days, SEO was all about keyword stuffing. Let's imagine you ran a pet shop. Writing a blog titled ‘Everything You Need to Know About Goldfish’ with the keyword "goldfish" repeated 30 times was an effective way to rank higher. Google would scan for these keywords, and businesses that flooded their content with them would magically appear at the top of search engine results.
While this strategy worked at the time, it led to a glut of low-quality content. Google soon adapted.
Semantic search and intent
Fast forward to the present, Google has replaced primitive keyword reliance with semantic search. Instead of keywords alone, it now focuses on context and user intent. For instance, if a user searches, “What time is the Phillies game?”, Google analyzes the phrase to understand what the user really wants and delivers answers accordingly. This approach aligns search results with the user's intent, not just individual words they've typed into the search bar.
To optimize for semantic search, businesses started focusing on creating high-quality, authoritative content rich in context and supported by H1 and H2 tags, lists, and well-outlined structures. This shift was welcome, as users got better answers, and businesses enjoyed a cleaner mechanism for traffic generation.
Featured snippets: The holy grail
Technical evolution also brought about the featured snippet—a short, highlighted text that answers a user’s query directly at the top of Google's search results page. Securing a snippet became the “gold standard” for SEO strategies. Businesses like Income School helped clients unlock this potential by teaching them to optimize their content precisely for this purpose.
Mike Gaston shared his own experience of experimenting with this tactic, mentioning an article he authored—How to Escape Wage Slavery. By successfully capturing a featured snippet for this topic, his article took the coveted top position on Google, driving significant traffic to his website and even corresponding to a YouTube video tied to the same subject.
Enter the game changer: AI
The explosion of Artificial Intelligence (AI) across major platforms has changed everything. With tools like ChatGPT, Google Bard, Gemini, and others entering the market, information accessibility has been radically transformed.
The initial excitement about AI in SEO
It’s no secret that marketers saw AI as a shiny new toy for SEO. The automation and scalability AI offered heralded a new gold rush: generating vast quantities of content, overwhelming websites with keywords and semantic phrasing, and optimizing processes like research, title writing, and idea generation.
However, this enthusiasm hid a critical vulnerability. AI, while enhancing content creation, also disrupted the very foundation on which businesses relied—Google ranking their original content in organic search results.
Why relying on AI for SEO is a huge mistake
According to Mike, the euphoria surrounding AI in SEO is misplaced. The reality is stark: Google doesn’t need your content anymore.
AI-generated answers on the SERP
Moving forward, Google is leaning heavily into its own proprietary AI systems. For example, Google's Gemini initiative can instantly answer user queries without referencing external content or pushing users to third-party websites. If you ask Gemini how to bake brownies, it whiskily provides an instant answer, often without even showing links to external sources.
Consider the monetization implications: The longer users stay on Google’s Search Engine Results Page (SERP), interacting with AI-generated snippets, the more revenue Google generates through its ad ecosystem. Businesses and content creators who once played a symbiotic role in providing content for ranking have now become incidental to Google’s operation.
Mike explains Google Gemini's current experimentation with displacing traditional organic rankings.
What about users?
User behavior is also changing rapidly. Increasingly, individuals are favoring AI solutions like ChatGPT instead of traditional search engines. AI offers instantaneous, contextually rich, and conversational results, becoming a direct competitor to Google itself.
OpenAI's challenge to Google
OpenAI, the parent company of ChatGPT, is positioning itself as Google's first major search competitor in decades. Many users now turn to ChatGPT for searches they would traditionally perform on Google. This alternative experience dramatically undermines Google's stranglehold over search behavior.
What does the future hold for content creators and marketers?
The prognosis for businesses relying solely on SEO looks grim. As AI continues developing, either through better AI-generated answers or user preference shifting further away from traditional search, businesses must quickly adapt.
What can businesses do?
Mike surprises viewers with pragmatic measures to counteract this incoming storm. Here's what you’ll need to focus on to regain control:
1. Build your audience
Audience building is mission-critical. Remember—when your customers come from Google, they aren't your audience; they're Google's. Start building direct relationships with your users through platforms like email, podcasts, YouTube, and even niche community initiatives.
2. Master outbound marketing
Outbound strategies like paid advertising, direct campaigns, and traditional media need reinvestment. Unlike inbound tactics like SEO, outbound marketing gives you definitive control over your messaging and market reach.
3. Spread your bets
Diversification is key in this new reality. Relying heavily on one platform, like Google or even a social media channel, spells disaster if those platforms change their algorithms or terms of use. Be everywhere your audience is.
Mike outlines the importance of not putting all marketing eggs in one basket.
4. Own your relationships
Mike’s ultimate piece of advice centers on owning relationships. Email databases filled with subscribers and paying customers are assets immune to algorithmic changes. Unlike rented space on Google or social media, email takes you directly into your audience's inbox.
Mike promotes utilizing email newsletters to retain direct access to audiences.
The takeaway
The rise of AI isn’t merely a disruptor—it’s a bulldozer for SEO as we know it. Google no longer needs third-party content, and users are embracing alternatives like ChatGPT for smarter, quicker searches. Businesses that fail to adapt will fall victim to the slow decline of search-driven relevance.
If you're reading this and wondering what to do next, start by taking Mike's advice: Build your own audience, master outbound strategies, diversify your approaches, and maintain direct control over your audience relationships. Because the rules have changed, but the chance to succeed remains—if you're willing to evolve.
For extra insights, sign up for Mike’s free newsletter here or check additional strategies on Mike’s website.
